Find their gift

Find their gift

Three quick questions. We'll pick three gifts.

Dear CustomLove

Dear CustomLove: My Brother Never Helps With Mom

By The CustomLove Team · 5 min read ·

A guided journal titled Dad, I Want to Hear Your Story on a white table

Dear CustomLove is our advice column. Each letter is a composite: the people are our recurring CustomLove cast, and the question is one many of our readers ask.

Dear CustomLove,

My mom Rosa is 67. She's still independent, mostly, but there are more appointments now: cardiology, eyes, the dentist she's been avoiding. I'm a paralegal and I'm single, so somehow it became my job to drive her to all of them. My brother Marcus lives fifteen minutes away. He teaches high-school chemistry and has two little kids, and every time I ask, it's "I can't this week."

I love my brother. But I'm keeping score, and I hate that I'm keeping score. Last Sunday at Mom's I said something sharp in front of his kids and now we're both being weird. How do I get him to help without it becoming a war?

Elena, San Antonio

Dear Elena,

You're tired, and you're carrying something heavy mostly on your own. Keeping score is what tired, fair-minded people do when the load is lopsided. It doesn't make you petty. It makes you someone who needs help and hasn't been able to get it yet.

We're not therapists. We're a small team who make gifts for people in love, and we've listened to a lot of love stories. Here's what we'd tell a friend, with the research we lean on.

You're not the only family having this fight

The Family Caregiver Alliance, a nonprofit that supports family caregivers, has a whole fact sheet on this, Caregiving with Your Siblings. Two of its points might help. First, siblings usually have no model for how to share a parent's care as adults, so it tends to fall on whoever lives closest or seems available. Second, caring for a parent stirs up old childhood roles. You may be fighting about who drives Mom to cardiology, while underneath it's about who was the responsible one at twelve.

Turn "you never help" into a plan

"You never help" is true from where you're standing. But it's a verdict, and verdicts make people defend themselves. A plan is easier to say yes to.

  • Make the invisible visible. Write down a month of what Mom needs: appointments, prescriptions, groceries, the calls with insurance. Marcus may honestly not know the size of it.
  • Offer him specific jobs that fit his life. He can't do Tuesday mornings during school. He might do every insurance call, the Saturday grocery run with the kids, or the pharmacy pickup on his way home.
  • Talk when it's calm, and alone. Not at Mom's, not in front of the kids. "I need your help and I'm running out of steam. Can we figure out a split?"
  • Include Mom. She's 67 and independent. Ask her what she'd actually like help with. The Caregiver Alliance suggests separating your parent's needs from your own.

The repair for Sunday

You said something sharp in front of his kids. A short, specific apology goes a long way: "I'm sorry I snapped on Sunday, especially in front of the girls. I'm worn out, and I took it out on you." Then ask for the conversation above. Our letter on how to say sorry properly has the steps.

Some siblings find that sharing the care goes easier when they also share something nice about Mom. Our "I Want to Hear Your Story" journal has prompts for a parent to answer about their life. One of you could bring it to appointments, the other to Sunday dinners, and fill it in together over a year.

Something to watch

McMaster University's short session Sibling Conflict in Family Caregiving covers exactly this, calmly and practically.

You and Marcus are on the same side, Elena: Mom's. Make the plan, ask for one specific thing, and let the score go once there's a split you can both live with.

With love,
CustomLove

If caregiving is wearing you down. Looking after a parent is real work, and burnout is common. To find local help for your mom (rides to appointments, meals, respite), the Eldercare Locator, a public service of the US Administration for Community Living, can connect you: call or text 1-800-677-1116. If you're struggling yourself, call or text 988 (988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline) any time.

Questions people ask

What do you do when siblings won't help with an elderly parent?

Make the work visible (list a month of what your parent needs), offer specific tasks that fit your sibling's life, talk when things are calm and private, and include your parent in deciding what help they want.

Why do siblings fight about caring for parents?

The Family Caregiver Alliance notes that siblings rarely have a model for sharing parent care as adults, and that caregiving can stir up childhood roles and old competition.

Where can I find help caring for an aging parent in the US?

The Eldercare Locator (US Administration for Community Living) connects families with local services: call or text 1-800-677-1116 or visit eldercare.acl.gov.

About Love & Advice. We're not therapists. We're a small team who make gifts for people in love, and we've listened to a lot of love stories. Nothing here is medical, psychological or legal advice; if something you're carrying feels heavy, please talk to someone trained to help. Have a question for Dear CustomLove? Ask us anonymously.

Love & Advice, Thursdays

One story or piece of advice a week. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Or ask us a question anonymously →