Find their gift

Find their gift

Three quick questions. We'll pick three gifts.

Dear CustomLove

Dear CustomLove: My Best Friend Is Getting Married and I Feel Left Behind

By The CustomLove Team · 5 min read ·

Three engraved open cuff bracelets reading YOU'RE MY PERSON in silver, gold and rose gold tones

Dear CustomLove is our advice column. Each letter is a composite: the people are our recurring CustomLove cast, and the question is one many of our readers ask.

Dear CustomLove,

My best friend Jada is getting married next fall. We've been best friends since we were roommates at Ohio State in 2010, and I'm going to be her maid of honor. I love her fiancé. I'm genuinely happy for her.

So why did I cry in my car after she asked me?

We live in different cities now (I'm in Denver, she's in Atlanta) and we've kept a Sunday walk-and-talk phone call going for years. Lately she's been planning during our calls, or cutting them short, and I feel like I'm watching her move into a life where I'm a guest. I'm single, I'm 34, and I hate that part of me is sad about the best news she's ever had. How do I stop feeling left behind?

Tess, Denver

Dear Tess,

You cried in your car because you love her, and because something is changing. Both of those can be true on the same day as being thrilled for her. Feeling a little grief inside a happy moment isn't selfish. It's what it feels like when someone matters this much.

We're not therapists. We're a small team who make gifts for people in love, and we've listened to a lot of love stories. Here's what we'd tell a friend, with the research we lean on.

What's actually changing (and what isn't)

A wedding changes the logistics of a friendship more than the substance of it. Jada will have less free time for a while, a new person to check things with, and a calendar that fills up with in-laws. What she won't lose is fifteen years of knowing you, including the terrible karaoke night you two still bring up.

It helps to know that friendships run on contact. A study of women's social networks by Sam Roberts and Robin Dunbar found that closer relationships had more recent contact, and that friendships needed more of it to stay close than family ties did (Roberts and Dunbar, 2011). That isn't a warning. It's a map: the friendship stays close if the contact continues, even when its shape changes.

Say the true thing, kindly

Jada may not know you feel this, because you've been doing a good job of being happy for her. Try something like: "I'm so excited for you. And I'll be honest, I'm also a little scared of losing our Sundays. Can we protect them?" Psychologist Marisa G. Franco, who studies adult friendship, makes the case in her TED talk that friendships last when we take the initiative instead of waiting to see if we're still wanted (The Secret to Making New Friends as an Adult, TED). Asking is initiative.

Three things to try this year

  • Keep the Sunday call, but split it. Twenty minutes of wedding, then a hard stop and "okay, tell me something that isn't about centerpieces." Most brides are relieved to have one place where they're not the bride.
  • Plan one thing that's only yours. A weekend, a dinner, a walk, before the wedding and after it. A standing tradition gives the friendship somewhere to live while everything else moves.
  • Make a friend of the fiancé. You already like him. Text him the photo of Jada at 19 in the dorm. People married to our best friends can be our biggest allies in keeping the friendship.

About feeling behind

Here's the gentle part. "Left behind" assumes everyone is on the same road, heading to the same place. You're not behind Jada. You're on your own road, and she's still on the phone with you every Sunday. If the single-at-34 feeling is the louder one, it deserves its own conversation, maybe with another friend who isn't planning a wedding.

Some maids of honor give their bride something small that's about the two of them rather than the wedding. Our You're My Person Cuff Bracelet is an open cuff engraved with three words, for the one you'd call first. A good one to give on a Sunday walk, not at the reception.

Something to watch

Shasta Nelson's TEDx talk Frientimacy: The 3 Requirements of All Healthy Friendships is a warm, practical look at what keeps a friendship close as life changes around it.

You're not losing her, Tess. You're learning a new version of the friendship. Say the true thing, protect the Sundays, and let yourself be sad and happy at the same time.

With love,
CustomLove

Questions people ask

Is it normal to feel sad when your best friend gets married?

Yes. Many people feel a mix of joy and grief when a close friend marries, because the friendship's routines are about to change. Saying so kindly, and protecting one regular way of staying in touch, usually helps more than hiding it.

How do you stay close to a best friend after they get married?

Keep a regular point of contact (a weekly call or walk), plan time that's just the two of you, and get to know their partner. Research on social networks suggests friendships stay close when contact continues.

What should a maid of honor give the bride?

Something about your friendship rather than the wedding: a letter, an old photo, or a small keepsake you give privately before the day.

Sources and further reading

About Love & Advice. We're not therapists. We're a small team who make gifts for people in love, and we've listened to a lot of love stories. Nothing here is medical, psychological or legal advice; if something you're carrying feels heavy, please talk to someone trained to help. Have a question for Dear CustomLove? Ask us anonymously.

Love & Advice, Thursdays

One story or piece of advice a week. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Or ask us a question anonymously →