Dear CustomLove
Dear CustomLove: How Do I Say Sorry Properly?
By The CustomLove Team · 6 min read ·

Dear CustomLove is our advice column. Each letter is a composite: the people are our recurring CustomLove cast, and the question is one many couples ask.
Dear CustomLove,
I'm not good at this stuff. I'm an electrician, I fix things, and I can't figure out how to fix this.
At my girlfriend Alyssa's sister's birthday, someone asked when we're getting engaged and I made a joke. Something like "when she stops making me watch baking shows." Everyone laughed. Alyssa didn't. On the drive home I said "sorry, it was a joke," and she said "that's not an apology." Now it's been three days of polite.
We've been together three years. I love her. What does a proper apology even look like?
Chris, Phoenix
Dear Chris,
The fact that you're asking how to fix it, three days in, instead of waiting for it to blow over, says a lot about you. Most of us have made exactly that kind of joke. The ones who stay close are the ones who go back and repair it.
We're not therapists. We're a small team who make gifts for people in love, and we've listened to a lot of love stories. Here's what the people who study apologies say.
Why "sorry, it was a joke" didn't land
Notice the two halves. "Sorry" was the apology. "It was a joke" was an explanation that quietly said "you shouldn't be hurt." Alyssa heard the second half louder. A joke about getting engaged, in front of her family, after three years, may have touched something she cares about a lot. Your apology needs to show you understand what it touched, not just that it was a joke.
What goes into an apology that works
Psychiatrist Aaron Lazare spent years studying apologies. In What an Apology Must Do (Greater Good Magazine, UC Berkeley), he describes up to four parts, and says a good apology has to meet at least one real need in the person who was hurt, such as getting their dignity back or knowing it won't happen again.
Greater Good's practical version, Making an Effective Apology, boils it down:
- Name what you did, specifically. "I made a joke about us getting engaged in front of your family."
- Explain briefly, without excusing. "I was uncomfortable with the question and I deflected." Stop there.
- Say you're sorry and mean the why. "I'm sorry. I think it made it look like I don't take us seriously, and I do."
- Offer to make it right. Ask: "What would help?" and listen.
The research behind that page (Lewicki, Polin and Lount, 2016) found that apologies with more of these parts were rated as more effective, and that two mattered most: acknowledging responsibility and offering to repair.
The Gottman Institute's mindful apology adds a short version you can remember on the spot: "Own, Repair, Improve." And it adds a step people forget: once it's been heard, begin again. A hug, a walk, dinner. Let it be over.
What to avoid
- "I'm sorry if you were upset." That puts it back on her.
- "I'm sorry, but..." Everything after "but" erases the sorry.
- Apologising by text when you could do it face to face.
- Needing her to say "it's fine" straight away. Give her room.
The conversation underneath
Chris, the joke was probably covering a question you haven't talked about yet: where you two are going. You don't have to have an answer. But "I deflected because I didn't know how to talk about it in front of everyone. Can we talk about it, just us?" might be the most important sentence in the whole apology.
Where a gift fits (and where it doesn't)
A gift is never the apology. Said first, it can feel like you're paying your way out. Given after the conversation, it can be the "make it right" part: proof you'll remember.
If you want something she can keep from that conversation, our Alluring Beauty apology necklace has a small ribbon-shaped pendant, made for exactly this moment. Say the words first. Then let the gift say you meant them.
Something to read and something to watch
Harriet Lerner's book Why Won't You Apologize? Healing Big Betrayals and Everyday Hurts (Touchstone, 2017; author's site) is the most readable book on this we know. And Brené Brown's The Power of Vulnerability (TED) explains why the hard, honest version is the one that works.
Go back. Name it. Mean it. Ask what would help. You can fix this.
With love,
CustomLove
A note on hurt that goes deeper. This letter is about an ordinary mistake between two people who feel safe with each other. If an apology in your relationship is part of a pattern of hurting, controlling or frightening, that's not something a better apology fixes, and you deserve support. The National Domestic Violence Hotline is free and confidential, 24/7: 1-800-799-7233. If you're in crisis or thinking about harming yourself, call or text 988 (988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline).
Questions people ask
How do you apologize to your partner properly?
Name what you did specifically, explain briefly without excusing it, say you're sorry and why it mattered, and ask what would help make it right. Research on apologies finds that taking responsibility and offering repair matter most.
What should you not say in an apology?
Avoid 'I'm sorry if you were upset' and 'I'm sorry, but'. Both shift the weight back onto the other person.
Should you give a gift when you apologize?
A gift can't replace the apology. Given after a real conversation, it can be part of making amends and a reminder that you meant it.
Sources and further reading
- What an Apology Must Do by Aaron Lazare, M.D., Greater Good Magazine (UC Berkeley)
- Making an Effective Apology, Greater Good in Action (UC Berkeley)
- The Art of the Mindful Apology: Why 'Sorry' is Not Enough by Dr. Cheryl Fraser, The Gottman Institute
- Manage Conflict: Repair and De-Escalate, The Gottman Institute
- Why Won't You Apologize? Healing Big Betrayals and Everyday Hurts by Harriet Lerner, Ph.D. (2017, Touchstone / Simon & Schuster)
- Video: The Power of Vulnerability | Brené Brown | TED (TED, YouTube)
- National Domestic Violence Hotline: 1-800-799-7233
- 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline: Call or text 988
About Love & Advice. We're not therapists. We're a small team who make gifts for people in love, and we've listened to a lot of love stories. Nothing here is medical, psychological or legal advice; if something you're carrying feels heavy, please talk to someone trained to help. Have a question for Dear CustomLove? Ask us anonymously.
