Love Stories
Denise and the Man Who Wants Nothing
By The CustomLove Team · 4 min read ·

A CustomLove story
Denise's dad, Walt, has said the same thing every December since 1998: "I don't need anything, sweetheart. Save your money."
For years she ignored him. She bought sweaters he didn't wear, a tablet he used as a coaster, a smart speaker he unplugged because "it listens." Last Christmas she gave up and got him socks. He said thank you, and meant it, and she drove home to Charlotte feeling like she'd failed a test nobody had set.
Denise is the gift person in her family. She remembers every birthday: her husband Mark's, her kids Tyler's and Ava's, her in-laws', the neighbor's dog's. She is very good at it. And she could not crack her own father.
The question
It started by accident in February. Walt called on a Sunday, as he does, to report on the weather and his knees. Ava, 13, was doing a school project on the 1970s and Denise, half listening, asked him: "Dad, what was your first car?"
He talked for forty minutes. A 1968 Plymouth Valiant, green, bought for $300 from a man whose wife had told him to sell it. The day the floor rusted through on the highway. Driving to her mom's parents' house in it, the first time he met them, with the passenger window stuck halfway down in November.
Denise had never heard any of it. She'd known him for 47 years.
So the next Sunday she asked another question. "What did you and Mom do on your first date?" Then: "What was the worst job you ever had?" "What did Grandpa say when you told him you were getting married?" She started writing the answers in a notebook by the phone.
What he actually wanted
By the summer, the Sunday call had changed. Walt started calling earlier. He'd say, "I thought of one for you," before she'd asked anything. Her brother noticed: "Dad sounds different." He did. He sounded like someone being listened to.
There's a reason this works that's bigger than one family. The Harvard Study of Adult Development has followed people for most of a century, and its clearest finding is that close relationships matter more to a long, happy life than money or fame. The study's director, Robert Waldinger, put it simply: "tending to your relationships is a form of self-care too" (Harvard Gazette).
Walt didn't need anything. He wanted to be asked.
Christmas, this year
Denise typed up the notebook. Forty-one stories, from the Valiant to the day she was born ("You were purple and furious"). She printed it at the office, put it in a binder, and wrote on the first page: Your stories, as told to me. More to come.
She's not sure yet how he'll take it. He may say "you shouldn't have." But she'll be watching for the moment he turns to the Valiant page, and she already knows what he'll say first: "The window was stuck all the way down, actually."
If your dad wants nothing
- Ask one question a call. Start easy: first car, first job, how he met your mom.
- Write the answers down the same day. You will forget details faster than you think.
- Give the stories back. Typed, printed, bound, read aloud at dinner, whatever suits your family.
- Bring the grandkids in. Kids ask better questions than adults, and grandparents answer them more honestly.
If you'd rather he wrote the stories himself, our "I Want to Hear Your Story" journal for Dad or Mom is a book of prompts with room for his answers, made to be filled in and handed back.
Something to watch
What Makes a Good Life? Lessons from the Longest Study on Happiness | Robert Waldinger (TED). Fifteen minutes, and you'll want to call your parents afterwards.
Denise is part of the CustomLove story cast: recurring characters we write about in our stories and our advice column, so you can get to know them over time.
Questions people ask
What do you get a dad who says he wants nothing?
Often what he wants is attention, not things: ask him one question about his life each call, write the answers down and give them back, or give a guided journal he can fill in.
What questions should I ask my parents about their life?
Start easy and concrete: your first car, your first job, how you met, the worst job you ever had, what your own parents said when you got married.
Sources and further reading
About Love & Advice. We're not therapists. We're a small team who make gifts for people in love, and we've listened to a lot of love stories. Nothing here is medical, psychological or legal advice; if something you're carrying feels heavy, please talk to someone trained to help. Have a question for Dear CustomLove? Ask us anonymously.
