Find their gift

Find their gift

Three quick questions. We'll pick three gifts.

Gift Guides

Meaningful Gifts for Your Best Friend, and Why Each One Works

By The CustomLove Team · 4 min read ·

A film-roll photo keychain pulled out to show a strip of photos, beside a card and roses

A meaningful gift for a best friend isn't about price. It's proof that you know them: the inside joke, the years, the version of them nobody else remembers. Every gift below is here for a reason, and we've written the reason down.

Two research findings guided the list:

  • Sentimental beats safe. Psychologists Julian Givi and Jeff Galak found that givers often choose gifts that match someone's stated tastes over sentimental ones, much more often than recipients would like, because the sentimental gift feels riskier (Givi and Galak, 2017). Your best friend is the person you can take that risk with.
  • It's about living with it, not unwrapping it. Givers fixate on the moment of the reveal; recipients care more about owning the gift afterwards (Galak, Givi and Williams, 2016). Choose something they'll wear, carry or use.

1. Permanent Bracelet Kit

Shop the kit. Two matching bracelets with the pliers and cutters in the box, closed on each other's wrists at home. The clasp is designed to stay closed once it's secured.

Why it works: it's a friendship bracelet, grown up, and a small ceremony at once. The meaning is in doing it together.

For: best friends like Denise and Renée, who've had each other's backs for 25 years and have nothing they both wear that says so.

2. You're My Person Cuff Bracelet

Shop the cuff. An open cuff engraved with three words.

Why it works: it says the thing friends rarely say out loud. It's a gift that doesn't need a card.

For: the one you'd call first. A good maid-of-honor gift, given privately.

3. Magnetic Heart Bracelets

Shop the pair. Each of you wears half a heart; when you're together, the halves click into one.

Why it works: it's a pair, so it's a gift for both of you. And it's a small reason to hold hands, or bump wrists, every time you meet.

For: long-distance best friends like Tess and Jada, Denver and Atlanta.

4. Retro Film Roll Photo Keychain

Shop the keychain. A tiny film canister that pulls out into a strip of 8 to 10 of your photos.

Why it works: it's a timeline of your friendship in their pocket. Pick photos only the two of you would understand.

For: a best friend moving away, or a milestone birthday.

5. Scent Memory Necklace

Shop the necklace. The pendant holds a scent pad for a fragrance you choose.

Why it works: a smell can bring a person back in a second. Your perfume, the candle from your shared apartment, the beach: something that smells like your friendship.

For: friends who've lived together, or the friend who's moving across the country.

6. A gift that costs nothing

The friendship letter. One page: the moment you knew you'd be friends, one thing they did that you've never forgotten, one thing you hope for you both. Hand-written. Pair it with any gift above, or give it on its own. It might be the one they keep longest.

Not sure how to keep a far-away friendship close the rest of the year? Read 10 Ways to Keep a Long-Distance Friendship Alive.

Good to know before you order

  • Delivery: about 15 days from order to door, for every order. Shipping is free.
  • Personalization: check names and dates carefully. Personalized items can only be refunded or replaced if they arrive damaged or defective (report it within 3 days of delivery), and engraving can be changed within 4 hours of ordering.

Tess and Jada, and Denise and Renée, are part of our recurring CustomLove story cast.

Questions people ask

What is a meaningful gift for a best friend?

Something that proves you know them: a matching piece you both wear, a timeline of your photos, a scent that reminds them of you, or a handwritten letter about your friendship.

Are sentimental gifts better than practical ones?

Research by Givi and Galak (2017) found recipients would like sentimental gifts more often than givers choose them; givers tend to play it safe.

How long does CustomLove take to deliver?

About 15 days from order to door for every order, with free shipping.

Sources and further reading

  • Givi & Galak (2017). Sentimental value and gift giving: Givers' fears of getting it wrong prevents them from getting it right. Journal of Consumer Psychology 27(4) (doi:10.1016/j.jcps.2017.06.002)
  • Galak, Givi & Williams (2016). Why Certain Gifts Are Great to Give but Not to Get. Current Directions in Psychological Science 25(6) (doi:10.1177/0963721416656937)

About Love & Advice. We're not therapists. We're a small team who make gifts for people in love, and we've listened to a lot of love stories. Nothing here is medical, psychological or legal advice; if something you're carrying feels heavy, please talk to someone trained to help. Have a question for Dear CustomLove? Ask us anonymously.

Love & Advice, Thursdays

One story or piece of advice a week. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Or ask us a question anonymously →