Find their gift

Find their gift

Three quick questions. We'll pick three gifts.

The Relationship Guide

Anxiety in Early Dating: Texting, Pacing and Letting It Be New

By The CustomLove Team · 4 min read ·

A young woman sitting by a window in a city apartment, her phone on the table beside a cup of tea

Nia, a UX designer in Chicago, met Andre at a friend's trivia night three months ago. It's going well. And yet: he took four hours to reply on Tuesday, and she wrote and deleted three follow-up texts, checked whether he'd been online, and asked two friends to interpret a thumbs-up.

If you've done the same, welcome. Early dating anxiety is extremely common, and it's not a sign that something is wrong with you or with them.

Nia is part of our recurring CustomLove story cast.

Why the beginning is the anxious part

At the start of a relationship you care a lot and know very little. Your brain fills the gaps, and it often fills them with worst cases. The National Institute of Mental Health puts it plainly: feeling anxious is a normal part of life. What sets anxiety disorders apart is anxiety that doesn't go away, shows up in many situations and gets worse over time (NIMH). Waiting-for-a-text anxiety is usually the first kind.

A word about attachment

Many people find attachment theory useful here. Greater Good Magazine describes four adult patterns often used by researchers: secure, anxious-preoccupied, dismissive-avoidant and fearful-avoidant. The anxious pattern sounds like wanting closeness and worrying the other person doesn't want it back. The hopeful part: research suggests these patterns can shift over time, and a first step is simply recognizing your own (How to Stop Attachment Insecurity From Ruining Your Love Life).

A gentle caution: attachment styles are a lens, not a diagnosis. Use them to understand yourself, not to label a three-month-old relationship.

Texting: a few rules that lower the temperature

  • A slow reply is usually just a busy person. Andre teaches band. Tuesday was a rehearsal day.
  • Say what you'd like, once. "I like hearing from you during the day" is clearer than a test of who texts first.
  • Don't double-text from fear. If you'd send it anyway, send it. If you're sending it to calm the worry, put the phone in another room for an hour.
  • Move the important stuff offline. Feelings, plans, worries: say them in person or on a call. Text is bad at tone.

Pacing: let it be new

Anxiety likes to fast-forward: Are we exclusive? Will he like my family? Where is this going? Try to stay in the month you're in. A few things that help:

  • Keep your life full. Friends, workouts, your own plans. A relationship is easier to enjoy when it isn't your only source of good news.
  • Notice the evidence. He knows your coffee order. He planned the last two dates. Anxiety skips the data; you don't have to.
  • Talk about it, lightly, when it's time. "I tend to overthink at the start of things. If I ever go quiet, that's probably why." It's a lovely thing to be able to say to someone.

Watch

Mandy Len Catron's TED talk Falling in love is the easy part is reassuring for anyone at the start of something: love is less about the right signals and more about choices you make together over time. And if a big question is coming up, try a few of the 36 Questions for Increasing Closeness together instead of guessing.

If the worry is bigger than dating. If anxiety is affecting your sleep, work or daily life, or you're having panic attacks, please talk to a doctor or a mental health professional; it's very treatable. If you're in crisis, call or text 988 (988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline), free and confidential, any time.

Questions people ask

Is anxiety in early dating normal?

Yes. Caring a lot while knowing little is a recipe for worry. NIMH notes that feeling anxious is a normal part of life; anxiety that doesn't go away, shows up everywhere and gets worse is worth talking to a professional about.

How do you stop overthinking texts in a new relationship?

Assume a slow reply is usually a busy person, say once how you like to stay in touch, don't send texts just to calm the worry, and keep important conversations for in person.

Can attachment styles change?

Greater Good Magazine reports research suggesting insecure attachment patterns can shift over time, and that recognizing your own pattern is a helpful first step.

About Love & Advice. We're not therapists. We're a small team who make gifts for people in love, and we've listened to a lot of love stories. Nothing here is medical, psychological or legal advice; if something you're carrying feels heavy, please talk to someone trained to help. Have a question for Dear CustomLove? Ask us anonymously.

Love & Advice, Thursdays

One story or piece of advice a week. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Or ask us a question anonymously →