Find their gift

Find their gift

Three quick questions. We'll pick three gifts.

Love Stories

Ben & Theo's Orphans Dinner: A Chosen-Family Friendsgiving

By The CustomLove Team · 5 min read ·

A long dinner table made from an old door, set for a Friendsgiving dinner with candles and houseplants

The first orphans dinner, in Ben and Theo's old one-bedroom in Minneapolis, had four guests, one borrowed folding table and a turkey breast that Theo cooked for two hours too long. It was November 2018. Ben, a nurse anesthetist, had a shift the next morning and couldn't fly home to his family in Iowa. Two friends from the hospital were stuck in town too. Theo's friend Marisol had stopped going home for the holidays years earlier and didn't really talk about why.

"We'll call it the orphans dinner," Theo said, putting out a second bottle of wine. "Anyone who's not going home, comes here."

How it grew

By the next year it was monthly, the second Sunday, all year round, and the folding table had become a door Theo found on the curb and refinished (he restores old furniture for a living, and has strong opinions about doors). Guests rotate. Some come every month. Some come once, in a hard year, and then don't need to. Nobody has to explain why they're there.

The November one is the big one. This year it seats fourteen, across the door-table and the kitchen island, plus whoever drifts in for pie.

The rules (Theo wrote them on a chalkboard)

  • Bring one dish that means something to you. Marisol brings her grandmother's arroz con leche. One of the hospital crew brings a green bean casserole from a can, every year, with pride.
  • No one does the dishes alone.
  • The toast goes around the table. Everyone says one thing they're grateful for this year. You can pass. Almost nobody does.
  • New people sit next to Ben. He's the better host. Theo is in charge of the plants and the playlist.
  • Someone takes one photo of everyone at the end, slightly blurry, every time.

What chosen family means at their table

"Chosen family" is the name for bonds people build on purpose, outside of blood or law, based on care and showing up. The idea is closely associated with LGBTQ communities, where many people have had to build family beyond the one they were born into (Chosen family, Wikipedia). Ben and Theo, married in 2021, both have families who love them. They also know plenty of people who don't, or whose families are too far away, or too complicated, to go home to.

And Friendsgiving, as a word, is young: Merriam-Webster dates its first use to 2007, though friends have shared Thanksgiving for decades (Friendsgiving, Wikipedia).

Why a dinner like this matters

A large review of 148 studies found that people with stronger social relationships had a 50% greater likelihood of survival over the study periods (Holt-Lunstad and colleagues, 2010). And a set of experiments by Kathleen Vohs and colleagues found that small rituals make experiences more enjoyable, especially when you take part in them yourself (Vohs and colleagues, 2013). A chalkboard of rules and a toast that goes around the table are exactly that.

Friendsgiving ideas to borrow from Ben & Theo

  1. Ask for dishes with stories, and let each person say a sentence about theirs before eating.
  2. The gratitude toast, with a right to pass.
  3. Mix the tables. Seat people next to someone they don't know yet.
  4. A shared playlist, each guest adds one song in advance.
  5. Make it repeat. One dinner is nice. A standing date turns it into a family.
  6. Keep a seat for a late arrival. Someone always gets off a shift at 8.
  7. Take the blurry photo. In five years, the stack of them will be the best thing you own.

If you'd like a year of those blurry photos somewhere you can carry them, our Retro Film Roll Photo Keychain pulls out into a tiny film strip of 8 to 10 of your pictures. A lovely thank-you for the friend who always hosts. If it's for Christmas, it takes about 15 days to reach you, so order by Dec 10.

Ben and Theo are part of the CustomLove story cast: recurring characters we write about in our stories and our advice column, so you can get to know them over time.

If the holidays are lonely this year. Not everyone has a table to go to, and the holidays can make that ache. If you're struggling, you don't have to carry it alone: call or text 988 (988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline), free and confidential, any time.

Questions people ask

What is Friendsgiving?

A Thanksgiving-style meal shared with friends, often by people who can't or don't go home to family. Merriam-Webster dates the word to 2007, though the idea is much older.

What are good Friendsgiving ideas?

Ask everyone to bring a dish that means something to them, go around with a gratitude toast, mix the seating, build a shared playlist, and make it a tradition you repeat.

What does chosen family mean?

Close bonds people build on purpose, outside of blood or legal ties, based on mutual care and support. The term is closely associated with LGBTQ communities.

Sources and further reading

About Love & Advice. We're not therapists. We're a small team who make gifts for people in love, and we've listened to a lot of love stories. Nothing here is medical, psychological or legal advice; if something you're carrying feels heavy, please talk to someone trained to help. Have a question for Dear CustomLove? Ask us anonymously.

Love & Advice, Thursdays

One story or piece of advice a week. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Or ask us a question anonymously →