Dear CustomLove
Dear CustomLove: We've Been Dating Three Months. Do I Get Him a Christmas Gift?
By The CustomLove Team · 5 min read ·

Dear CustomLove is our advice column. Each letter is a composite: the people are our recurring CustomLove cast, and the question is one many of our readers ask.
Dear CustomLove,
I've been seeing Andre for three months. He's a high-school band teacher, we met at a friend's trivia night, and it's going really well. Like, he-knows-my-coffee-order well.
Christmas is coming and I'm spiraling. If I get him something and he doesn't get me anything, I'll want to disappear. If I get nothing and he shows up with a gift, I'll want to disappear. If I get something too big, it's "a lot." Too small and it's "oh." I've drafted and deleted the text "are we doing gifts?" four times. Help.
Nia, Chicago
Dear Nia,
First: you're not spiraling because you're bad at this. You're spiraling because you like him, and a gift feels like a public statement about how much. At three months, everyone feels this. Andre is very likely drafting and deleting his own text right now.
We're not therapists. We're a small team who make gifts for people in love, and we've listened to a lot of love stories. Here's what we'd tell a friend, with the research we lean on.
Just ask. Lightly.
The text you keep deleting is the right text. You just need a lighter version. Try: "Are we doing Christmas gifts? I vote small and silly." It names the question, sets a size, and makes it fun instead of a test. If he says no gifts, you've lost nothing. If he says yes, you both know the rules.
What makes a gift land at three months
Gift research has a useful finding for you. Psychologists Jeff Galak, Julian Givi and Elanor Williams describe a gap between givers and receivers: givers focus on the moment of opening, while recipients care more about what it's like to own the thing afterwards (Galak, Givi and Williams, 2016). In plain English: the "wow" matters less than you think. The "oh, this is so me" matters more.
And a second one. Julian Givi and Jeff Galak found that givers often skip sentimental gifts because they're unsure they'll be liked, even though recipients would often prefer them (Givi and Galak, 2017). At three months you don't need a big sentimental gesture. But a small one, built on something only you'd know, beats anything generic.
A three-month gift has three rules
- Small in size, specific in meaning. The coffee order you already know. The band he won't stop talking about. A joke from your second date.
- Nothing that needs a conversation. No keys to your place, no matching anything, no engraved date (yet). Save those for when you both want them.
- Easy to receive. If he got you something small, it should feel like a match, not an overmatch.
Some ideas: a mixtape-style playlist with a note about why each song is on it. Tickets to something in January, so the gift is also a plan. A paperback you loved with your notes in the margins.
If you'd like something small with a little surprise in it, our Personalized Hidden Message Candle hides a short message that appears as the wax melts. Keep the message light at three months: an inside joke works better than a declaration. It takes about 15 days to reach you, so order by Dec 10 for Christmas.
And if the gifts don't match?
Then one of you says "oh, I didn't get you anything!" and the other says "it's tiny, I just saw it and thought of you." That's not a disaster. That's a story you'll tell later. Mandy Len Catron, who wrote about falling in love through 36 questions, says in her TED talk that falling in love is the easy part, and the rest is a series of small choices (Falling in love is the easy part, TED). A mismatched gift is one of those choices: to laugh about it together.
Send the light text, Nia. Then go back to enjoying a very good three months.
With love,
CustomLove
Questions people ask
Should you get a Christmas gift for someone you just started dating?
If you've been seeing each other a couple of months or more, a small gift is usually welcome. The easiest way to avoid a mismatch is to ask lightly first: 'Are we doing gifts? I vote small and silly.'
What's a good gift for someone you've been dating three months?
Something small and specific to them: a playlist with notes, tickets to something you'll do together soon, a book you loved. Avoid gifts that imply a big commitment, like keys or engraved dates.
When should I order a CustomLove gift for Christmas?
Everything takes about 15 days to reach you, so order by December 10.
Sources and further reading
- Galak, Givi & Williams (2016). Why Certain Gifts Are Great to Give but Not to Get. Current Directions in Psychological Science 25(6) (doi:10.1177/0963721416656937)
- Givi & Galak (2017). Sentimental value and gift giving: Givers' fears of getting it wrong prevents them from getting it right. Journal of Consumer Psychology 27(4) (doi:10.1016/j.jcps.2017.06.002)
- Video: Falling in love is the easy part | Mandy Len Catron | TED (TED, YouTube)
About Love & Advice. We're not therapists. We're a small team who make gifts for people in love, and we've listened to a lot of love stories. Nothing here is medical, psychological or legal advice; if something you're carrying feels heavy, please talk to someone trained to help. Have a question for Dear CustomLove? Ask us anonymously.
