Dear CustomLove
Dear CustomLove: It's Our First Valentine's Day Together. How Big Do We Go?
By The CustomLove Team · 4 min read ·

Dear CustomLove is our advice column. Each letter is a composite: the people are our recurring CustomLove cast, and the question is one many of our readers ask.
Dear CustomLove,
I wrote to you about Christmas gifts. I'm already thinking about Valentine's Day, because of course I am. It'll be our first one together.
We'll be about six months in. I don't want a fancy prix-fixe dinner where everyone is staring at each other over a rose. But doing nothing feels like we're pretending it isn't happening. He teaches band and has a school concert that week, so he's going to be exhausted. What's a first Valentine's that's actually us?
Nia, Chicago
Dear Nia,
Planning ahead isn't overthinking when it saves you a panic in February. And you've already done the hard part of this letter: you know you don't want the performance, and you don't want to skip it. That narrows things nicely.
We're not therapists. We're a small team who make gifts for people in love, and we've listened to a lot of love stories. Here's what we'd tell a friend, with the research we lean on.
A first Valentine's is a small ritual, not an exam
The pressure of a first Valentine's comes from treating it as a test of how serious you are. Try thinking of it as the first time you invent a tradition together. It's allowed to be small. Traditions usually start that way.
Research on gifts helps here too. Psychologists who study giving find that givers fixate on the moment of the reveal, while recipients care more about living with the gift afterwards (Galak, Givi and Williams, 2016). The same goes for dates: you'll remember the slightly burnt pancakes and the laughing more than the restaurant.
Ideas that fit a tired band teacher
- Valentine's on a different night. The 14th is a school week for him. Pick the Saturday after and call it yours. Quieter restaurants, no pressure.
- Something new for both of you. A cooking class, a pottery night, a dance lesson. Couples who try something new and a little challenging together tend to feel closer afterwards (Aron and colleagues, 2000).
- The questions night. Takeout, couch, and a few of Arthur Aron's 36 Questions for Increasing Closeness. At six months, it's a lovely way to learn the things you haven't asked yet.
- Go to his concert. Honestly, this might be the biggest gift. Sit in the back. Bring flowers for after.
What to give at six months
Keep the same rule as Christmas: small in size, specific in meaning. A note about the night you met at trivia. A framed photo from your first weekend away. Tickets to a show for March. Save engraving and matching pieces for when you both bring them up.
If you'd like flowers that will still be on his desk in March, our Glitter Rose Bouquet is made of glitter-coated faux roses that won't wilt. A nice one to hand over after the concert. It takes about 15 days to arrive, so order early for Valentine's.
Talk about it first (yes, really)
"Do you want to do something for Valentine's? I'm thinking low-key, maybe the Saturday after your concert?" It's not unromantic to plan together. It's how you make sure you both enjoy it.
Make it small, make it yours, Nia. Then do it again next year and you'll have a tradition.
With love,
CustomLove
Questions people ask
What should you do for your first Valentine's Day together?
Something small that feels like you both: a new activity together, a quiet night with good questions, or a date on a less busy night. Talk about it first so you both enjoy it.
What's a good first Valentine's gift?
Small and specific: a note about how you met, a photo from a trip, tickets to something you'll do together. Leave engraved or matching pieces until you both bring them up.
How long does a CustomLove gift take to arrive?
About 15 days from order to door, so order early for Valentine's Day.
Sources and further reading
- Galak, Givi & Williams (2016). Why Certain Gifts Are Great to Give but Not to Get. Current Directions in Psychological Science 25(6) (doi:10.1177/0963721416656937)
- Aron, Norman, Aron, McKenna & Heyman (2000). Couples' shared participation in novel and arousing activities and experienced relationship quality. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 78(2)
- 36 Questions for Increasing Closeness by Arthur Aron, Ph.D. (source), Greater Good in Action (UC Berkeley)
- Aron, Melinat, Aron, Vallone & Bator (1997). The Experimental Generation of Interpersonal Closeness: A Procedure and Some Preliminary Findings. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 23(4) (doi:10.1177/0146167297234003)
About Love & Advice. We're not therapists. We're a small team who make gifts for people in love, and we've listened to a lot of love stories. Nothing here is medical, psychological or legal advice; if something you're carrying feels heavy, please talk to someone trained to help. Have a question for Dear CustomLove? Ask us anonymously.
