Find their gift

Find their gift

Three quick questions. We'll pick three gifts.

Dear CustomLove

Dear CustomLove: My Husband Says Gifts Don't Matter

By The CustomLove Team · 5 min read ·

Silver heart-shaped calendar keychain engraved with a circled date, beside a round "love you" tag

Dear CustomLove is our advice column. Each letter is a composite: the people are our recurring CustomLove cast, and the question is one many couples ask.

Dear CustomLove,

I'm the gift person in our house. Twenty-one years married to Mark, two teenagers, Tyler and Ava, and I remember every birthday in the family, including my dad's (he's 74 and says he wants nothing, which I've stopped believing).

Every December Mark says, "Don't get me anything, I mean it." Last year I took him at his word. He was fine. I was not. It felt like we'd skipped something. Then on my birthday he gave me a nice gift card and I felt ungrateful for wishing it had been, I don't know, more him.

Am I making too much of gifts? Should I just stop?

Denise, Charlotte

Dear Denise,

You're not making too much of anything. You noticed that something small had gone missing, and you're asking about it instead of resenting it quietly. That's a very good instinct after 21 years.

We're not therapists. We're a small team who make gifts, so yes, we have a bias, and we'll be honest about it. But this question isn't really about gifts, and we think you know that.

"Don't get me anything" usually means something else

When people say it, they rarely mean "I don't want to be thought of." More often they mean "I don't want you to spend money," "I don't want another thing to find a place for," or "I don't know how to receive this well." Mark may be trying to make life easier for you. The trouble is that the giving was part of how you feel close, and he's taken it off the table without realising.

What the research on love languages actually found

You've probably heard of Gary Chapman's The Five Love Languages (1992): words of affirmation, quality time, receiving gifts, acts of service, physical touch. The idea is that each of us has a primary "language," and that couples do better when they speak each other's.

In 2024, psychologists Emily Impett, Gideon Park and Amy Muise looked at the studies that have tested this. Their verdict on the matching idea: "There's no support for this matching effect" (University of Toronto News). People were happier when they received any of these expressions of love. They suggest thinking of it as a balanced diet: keep every kind of love on the menu, and tell each other what you need at different times.

That's freeing for you. You don't have to decide whether Mark is "not a gifts person." You just need to say what you need this year.

Try saying the true sentence

Something like: "I know you don't want me to spend money on you. But choosing something for you is one of the ways I feel close to you. Can I do it, and keep it small?" And the harder half: "On my birthday, I'd love something that's clearly from you, even if it's tiny."

It feels exposing to ask. Brené Brown's short animated talk Brené Brown on Empathy (Royal Society of Arts) is a good reminder of why saying the real thing usually brings people closer rather than pushing them away.

The gift that isn't a thing

If Mark truly wants nothing that needs a shelf, give him something he already has: a date. Write down the five days that mattered most in your 21 years, the ones he'd remember too, and give him the list with a reason for each. It costs nothing and it says, "I was paying attention the whole time."

And for your dad, the man who wants nothing: what most dads in their seventies want is to be asked. Ask him one question about his life every time you call this winter, and write the answers down.

If you'd like the date to live somewhere small, our Custom Love Calendar Keychain is a heart-shaped calendar engraved with one date and your names. It goes on his keys and doesn't need a shelf.

Don't stop giving, Denise. Give smaller, say why, and ask for what you'd like back.

With love,
CustomLove

Questions people ask

What do you get someone who says they don't want anything?

Something that doesn't need a shelf: an experience, a handwritten list of memories, a date that matters to you both, or a small everyday item with a personal detail. Ask what 'nothing' means to them: often it means 'don't spend much'.

Do love languages really matter?

A 2024 review by Impett, Park and Muise found no support for the idea that couples need to match love languages. People were happier receiving any expression of love, so it helps to keep all of them in play and say what you need.

Is it okay to tell my partner I want a gift?

Yes. Saying what you'd like, and why it matters to you, is usually clearer and kinder than hoping they guess.

About Love & Advice. We're not therapists. We're a small team who make gifts for people in love, and we've listened to a lot of love stories. Nothing here is medical, psychological or legal advice; if something you're carrying feels heavy, please talk to someone trained to help. Have a question for Dear CustomLove? Ask us anonymously.

Love & Advice, Thursdays

One story or piece of advice a week. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Or ask us a question anonymously →